24 October 2012

Is the noPhoto illegal?

See here how it works:
1. The traffic camera fires its flash to illuminate your car for a picture
2. The noPhoto detects the flash, analyzes it, and sends the proper firing sequence to its own xenon flashes.
3. The noPhoto precisely times and fires the flash at the exact moment needed to overexpose the traffic camera.
4. Since the traffic camera is not expecting the additional light from the noPhoto, all of its automated settings are incorrect and the image is completely overexposed.  Your license plate cannot be seen and you will not get a ticket in the mail.
Is it illegal? They say no:
Is the noPhoto legal? 
Since there is nothing physically covering or obscuring the license plate, the noPhoto does not violate any license plate cover laws.  Quite literally, we are using the same light and the same bulbs that red light and speed cameras do.  The noPhoto does not cover any state names, and there are no laws in existence regulating how much light is cast onto the license plate.
Unless the creators actually examined the laws of all 50 states (and DC), I suspect this is a dubious explanation; especially if they only looked specifically for "license plate cover laws." Here is Maryland's law:
Md. TRANSPORTATION Code Ann. § 21-1112.1: "(a) In general. -- A person may not obscure or modify any vehicle registration plate with intent to avoid identification."
As a reminder, IANAL(Y).

It makes sense to read this as applying to license plate covers (like these), but there is no language in this statute that indicates covers. So it makes sense that it should also apply to any method that obscures the license plate, even if it's not part of a cover. Lastly, the specific intent here, as declared above, is "to avoid identification." The legislature intended the law to prohibit people from trying to hide their plates, by any means (whether a cover or a flash device that didn't exist when the law was written).

I laud the creativity, and hope that people will continue to push the limits. But my reading and understanding of this statute, as it applies in Maryland, is that the noPhoto would be considered in violation.

10 comments:

Unknown said...

It doesn't obscure the plate. Any person looking at it can see it. It only prevents a camera from taking a picture of it.

theprez98 said...

The flash obscures the view of the plate when the camera takes the photo. You can argue about the technicality of it, but if you trust that the noPhoto is legal, I encourage you to come to Maryland and set up a test case. :-)

Unknown said...

No, it doesn't obscure the plate. The plate can be seen at all times. It does not prevent reading of the plate by a PERSON. You seem to be arguing that a machine has to be able to photograph the plate. That is not the case. It would be very hard for someone to argue that a plate has been obscured just because you can't photograph it.

theprez98 said...

Would a person be able to read the plate in the instant when the noPhoto fires its own flash? No.

If you're so confident of its legality, you ought to be willing to make a test case here in Maryland or any other state. Otherwise, how can customers believe it will actually survive in court?

theprez98 said...

Lt me be clear that I personally do note like speed cameras, and I'd like to see them disappear. But you need a stronger argument, because it will not survive in court.

theprez98 said...

By the way, Paul, are you the creator, or just an interested party?

Unknown said...

Related to the inventor.

The product isn't shipping yet. There will be test cases in many places when it does.

There is no realistic way to claim that a person can't identify the car because for one fraction of a second there is a flash. By the way, even without the NoPhoto, the reflection of the flash from the speed camera off the plate will have the same effect of "obscuring" the plate so that argument won't fly either. With OR without the NoPhoto, you have that same problem for someone looking at the plate because either way there is too much light for you to see it for that instant. The only difference is that one can be photographed and one cannot.

theprez98 said...

I'm not convinced that any of your arguments will hold any weight in court. Nonetheless, and despite my reservations about its legality, please let the inventor know that I am very interested in following the development of the device.

Unknown said...

My question would no be is it legal, but how diffitcult would it be to detect it on your vehicle? Who cares if it is legal if it can't be detected. A law is useless if it can't be enforced.

theprez98 said...

Maybe.