This is one in a series of posts designed to describe court decisions in plain English. For more detail and background on the legal issues, see the link to the case below. For similar posts, click here.
Case: United States v. Andrew Auernheimer
Case: United States v. Andrew Auernheimer
Background: Andrew Auernheimer ("Weev") was convicted of violating the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) by collecting the email addresses of iPad customers through an "account slurper" program.
Issues: (1) Did Auernheimer and Spitler access a computer “without authorization” under 18 U.S.C. § 1030(a)(2)(C)?
(2) If Auernheimer was properly convicted of a conspiracy to violate the CFAA, was that conspiracy a misdemeanor or a felony?
(3) Did Auernheimer violate the identity theft statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1028(a)(7)?
(4) Was venue proper in the District of New Jersey?
(5) Do AT&T’s costs in mailing a letter to its customers support an eight-level upward adjustment under the United States Sentencing Guidelines?
Issues: (1) Did Auernheimer and Spitler access a computer “without authorization” under 18 U.S.C. § 1030(a)(2)(C)?
(2) If Auernheimer was properly convicted of a conspiracy to violate the CFAA, was that conspiracy a misdemeanor or a felony?
(3) Did Auernheimer violate the identity theft statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1028(a)(7)?
(4) Was venue proper in the District of New Jersey?
(5) Do AT&T’s costs in mailing a letter to its customers support an eight-level upward adjustment under the United States Sentencing Guidelines?
Holding: The Third Circuit ruled that trying Auernheimer in New Jersey, where no elements of the crime occurred, denied Auernheimer’s substantial right to be tried in the place where his alleged crime was committed. As a result, it reversed the decision of the District Court and vacated his conviction. Weev was released on Friday night to the custody of his lawyer, Tor Ekeland.
It is important to note that the Third Circuit did not rule on the CFAA in this case. Venue is a threshold issue; by deciding the venue was improper, the District Court never had jurisdiction to hear the case. Venue is a procedural matter that doesn't go to the substance of the underlying charges. That is why it is possible that Weev could likely be charged again without violating double jeopardy, see i.e., Haney v. Burgess, 799 F.2d 661 (11th Cir. 1986) (retrial of a defendant whose conviction was reversed because of improper venue does not violate double jeopardy).
It is important to note that the Third Circuit did not rule on the CFAA in this case. Venue is a threshold issue; by deciding the venue was improper, the District Court never had jurisdiction to hear the case. Venue is a procedural matter that doesn't go to the substance of the underlying charges. That is why it is possible that Weev could likely be charged again without violating double jeopardy, see i.e., Haney v. Burgess, 799 F.2d 661 (11th Cir. 1986) (retrial of a defendant whose conviction was reversed because of improper venue does not violate double jeopardy).

No comments:
Post a Comment