Showing posts with label surveillance state. Show all posts
Showing posts with label surveillance state. Show all posts

23 November 2013

Here are my ShmooCon submissions

I made two submissions to ShmooCon this year. The first is a full-fledged talk and the second is a "One Track Mind" 20-minute talk. Here are the abstracts, and wish me luck!

©opyright Gone Wrong: Our Broken System and How We Can Fix It

The Constitution grants the Congress the power to enact intellectual property laws "[t]o promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." Since the founding of our country, protection of intellectual property has undergone several systematic changes that have extended the time rights are protected. Additionally, protections have gotten increasingly aggressive and oppressive. This presentation will briefly discuss the history and development of IP law, and then focus on the more recent and onerous provisions that have become embroiled in controversy. Along the way, we'll talk about the Digital Millennium Copyright Act,  copyright and patent trolls, and other methods of intellectual property abuse. Lastly, we will take a look at some of the ways we can reform our broken system to free consumers from burdensome restraints, while at the same time protecting the intellectual property of the creators.


In Washington, DC, the federal government is arguing against a prolific Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requester that his multitudinous requests, taken together, constitute a "mosaic" of information whose release could "significantly and irreparably damage national security" and would have "significant deleterious effects" on the bureau's "ongoing efforts to investigate and combat domestic terrorism." In the District of Columbia, the federal government is defending the legality of the intelligence community's surveillance programs under a 1979 Supreme Court case, Smith v. Maryland, that found constitutional use of a “pen register” device to gather information on numbers called by a criminal suspect. So, yes: the government is simultaneously arguing to that too much otherwise-legitimate FOIA data creates a mosaic that threatens national security--but large scale metadata collection, far beyond anything contemplated by a simple pen register device in 1979--is perfectly legitimate. Is this a problematic dichotomy? And if so, what can we do about it?

20 November 2013

Having your cake and eating it too: FOIA, surveillance, and individual privacy


It seems pretty obvious now (if it hasn't already been for a long time!) that the government wants to have its cake and eat it, too. On one hand, the federal government is arguing against a prolific Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requester:
...the FBI claims that Shapiro's multitudinous requests, taken together, constitute a "mosaic" of information whose release could "significantly and irreparably damage national security" and would have "significant deleterious effects" on the bureau's "ongoing efforts to investigate and combat domestic terrorism."
Disparate items of information, though individually of limited or no utility to their possessor, can take on added significance when combined with other items of information. Combining the items illuminates their interrelationships and breeds analytic synergies, so that the resulting mosaic of information is worth more than the sum of its parts.
On the other hand, in response to claims that the NSA's metadata collection program violates the Fourth Amendment:
...Gilligan argued that the government also believes the surveillance is legal under a 1979 Supreme Court case, Maryland v. Smith [sic], that found constitutional use of a “pen register” device to gather information on numbers called by a criminal suspect. 
“In terms of computer technology, things have changed an awful lot since ’79,” Leon replied. “The technology used in that case pales in comparison — pales in comparison to the technology NSA has at its disposal to query hundreds of millions of records … maybe billions of records in a matter of minutes or hours.” 
“Smith’s value may be very limited if at all in this case,” the judge added.
The mosaic theory of the Fourth Amendment suggests that the aggregate collection of information over an extended period of time may be considered a search. As Justice Ginsberg wrote in United States v. Jones (the GPS monitoring case), "[w]hen considered as a collective whole, the monitoring...revealed an intimate picture of the subject's life that he expects no one to have..."

So, yes: the government is simultaneously arguing to that too much otherwise-legitimate FOIA data creates a mosaic that threatens national security--but large scale metadata collection, far beyond anything contemplated by a simple pen register device in 1979--is perfectly legitimate. Both of these arguments are being made in the same city--Washington, DC--and in fact in the same court--the United States District Court for the District of Columbia. Right hand, meet the left hand.

I've submitted a CFP to Shmoocon to further discuss this issue, so if it gets picked up, I'll be able to flesh it out further.

What do you think?

11 August 2013

No, AT&T is not charging customers a Lawful Interception Recovery Fee

For more information, follow me on Twitter.

I guess they don't tap my phone because this isn't on my AT&T statement (I just checked). What is $0.61 for? It's not even lined up correctly. Five line items, six charges? Bad math? Also, why is everyone across the entire Internet posting the same image? If they're doing this to everyone, why isn't everyone posting their own respective phone bills? Looks like bad photoshop to me. If there is evidence out there to prove me wrong, please share and I'll be the first one to admit I was wrong. Until then, I call fake.

Edited to add (8/11/13): Even if this is a legitimate, CALEA-based lawful intercept fee, that doesn't make it "NSA"-related. Two very different things.

Update (8/12/13): Nearly 10,000 people have viewed this post in the last 24 hours!

Update (8/12/13): Snopes has now this as false. They contacted AT&T who confirmed as much.

17 March 2013

Surveillance State: The Home Depot

The Home Depot nearest me (and presumably others like it) recently installed motion-activated security cameras (and monitors) all over the store and at the registers that beep annoyingly while recording. According to an employee, they're for loss prevention purposes (presumably in addition to the normal cameras that most stores already have installed).